Juxtaposing Fiduciary Constitutionalism and Administrative Constitutionalism in the Context of Enhancing the Indonesian Constitution

Authors

  • David Tan Faculty of Laws, Universitas Internasional Batam

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21776/ub.blj.2021.008.02.02

Keywords:

administrative constitutionalism, constitution, fiduciary constitutionalism, government, legislative

Abstract

A lot of literature discusses the role of state administration, but there is still very little that emphasizes the unique picture related to juxtaposing aspects of fiduciary constitutionalism with administrative constitutionalism, especially at the stage of constitutional legal studies with the context of constitutionalism in Indonesia. Implementing a fiduciary state administration is very much needed, but the most significant obstacle is the enigma of administrative constitutionalism. The purpose of this inquiry is to analyze the development of the Indonesian Constitution in the future by elaborating the theory of fiduciary constitutionalism, issues related to administrative constitutionalism, and discussions related to the incorporation of the former and the latter into the practice of legal and political representation in the Indonesian Constitution using the perspective of judicial engagement theory. The research method used is the doctrinal legal approach using secondary data in the legal literature to gain academic insight. This research finally leads to a conclusion that focuses on the aspects of fiduciary and administrative constitutionalism, which can explain this phenomenon in enhancing the Constitution in Indonesia through several internalized recommendations.

References

Books

Evanty, Nukila, 'Komnas HAM: Discrepancies Between Its Mandate and the Indonesian Constitutional Framework' in James Gomez and Robin Ramcharan (eds), National Human Rights Institutions in Southeast Asia (Palgrave Macmillan, 1st ed, 2020) 141

Fox-Decent, Evan, Sovereignty’s Promise: The State as Fiduciary (Oxford University Press, 2011)

Gold, Andrew S, 'The State as a Wrongful Fiduciary' in Evan J Criddle et al. (eds), Fiduciary Government (Cambridge University Press, 2018) 183

Lindsey, Tim, and Simon Butt, 'State Power to Restrict Religious Freedom: An Overview of the Legal Framework' in Tim Lindsey and Helen Pausacker (eds), Religion, Law, and Intolerance in Indonesia (Routledge, First, 2016) 19

Miller, Paul B, 'Fiduciary Representation' in Evan J Criddle et al. (eds), Fiduciary Government (Cambridge University Press, 2018) 21

Underkoffler, Laura S, 'Fiduciary Theory: The Missing Piece for Positive Rights' in Evan J Criddle et al. (eds), Fiduciary Government (Cambridge University Press, 2018) 96

Journal Articles

Ablavsky, Gregory, ‘Administrative Constitutionalism and the Northwest Ordinance’ (2019) 167(7) University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1631

Bernstein, David E, ‘Antidiscrimination Laws and the Administrative State: A Skeptic’s Look at Administrative Constitutionalism’ (2019) 94(3) Notre Dame Law Review 1381

Bertrand, Jacques, ‘Indonesia’s Quasi-Federalist Approach: Accommodation Amid Strong Integrationist Tendencies’ (2007) 5(4) International Journal of Constitutional Law 576

Coglianese, Cary, ‘Dimensions of Delegation’ (2019) 167(7) University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1849

Dalal, Anjali S, ‘Shadow Administrative Constitutionalism and the Creation of Surveillance Culture’ (2014) 2014(1) Michigan State Law Review 59

Das, Alina, ‘Administrative Constitutionalism in Immigration Law’ (2018) 98(2) Boston University Law Review 485

Davis, Seth, ‘The False Promise of Fiduciary Government’ (2014) 89(3) Notre Dame Law Review 1145

Dunigan, Meaghan, ‘The Intelligible Principle: How It Briefly Lived, Why It Died, and Why It Desperately Needs Revival in Today’s Administrative State Why It Desperately Needs Revival in Today’s Administrative Stat’ (2017) 91(1) St. John’s Law Review 247

Green, Michael J, ‘Authorization and Political Authority in Hobbes’ (2015) 53(1) Journal of the History of Philosophy 25

Griesinger, Joanna L, 'Municipal Administrative Constitutionalism: The New York City Commission on Human Rights, Foreign Policy, and the First Amendment (2019) 167(7) University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1669

Ituarte-Lima, Claudia, Constance L McDermott, and Mari Mulyani, 'Assessing Equity in National Legal Frameworks for REDD+: The Case of Indonesia' (2014) 44 Environmental Science & Policy 291

Kim, Sung Hui, ‘The Last Temptation of Congress: Legislator Insider Trading and the Fiduciary Norm Against Corruption’ (2013) 98(4) Cornell Law Review 845

Kurniaty, R,” Human security in the age of electoral democracy: politico-business alliances

in the Malang regency, Indonesia,” International Journal Sustainable Future for Human Security, JSustaiN Vol.7 No. 12-10, 2020

Lawson, Gary, and Guy I Seidman, 'Authors' Response: An Enquiry Concerning Constitutional Understanding' (2019) 17 Georgetown Journal of Law & Public Policy 491

Lee, Sophia Z, 'Our Administered Constitution: Administrative Constitutionalism From the Founding to the Present (2019) 167(7) University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1699

Leib, Ethan J and Stephen R Galoob, ‘Fiduciary Political Theory: A Critique’ (2016) 125(7) Yale Law Journal 1820

Leib, Ethan J, and Jeb Handelsman Shugerman, 'Fiduciary Constitutionalism: Implications for Self-Pardons and Non-Delegation' (2019) 17(2) The Georgetown Journal of Law & Public Policy 463

Lewis, Matthew, 'Administrative Constitutionalism and the Unity of Public Law' (2018) 55(2) Osgoode Hall Law Journal 515

Loughlin, Martin, ‘The Concept of Constituent Power’ (2014) 13(2) European Journal of Political Theory 218

Miller, Paul B, and Andrew S Gold, 'Fiduciary Governance' (2016) 57(2) William & Mary Law Review 513

Murray, Yxta Maya, ‘What FEMA Should Do After Puerto Rico: Toward Critical Administrative Constitutionalism’ (2019) 72(1) Arkansas Law Review 165

Patterson, Dennis, ‘The Dark Future of Constitutionalism’ (2015) 30 Constitutional Commentary 667

Pettit, Philip, ‘Representation, Responsive and Indicative’ (2010) 17(3) Constellations 426

Rahman, K Sabeel, ‘Domination, Democracy, and Constitutional Political Economy in the New Gilded Age: Towards a Fourth Wave of Legal Realism?’ (2016) 94(7) Texas Law Review 1329

Rave, D Theodore, ‘Politicians as Fiduciaries’ (2013) 126(3) Harvard Law Review 671

Ross, Bertrall L, ‘Administrative Constitutionalism as Popular Constitutionalism’ (2019) 167(7) University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1783

Ross, Bertrall L, ‘Denying Deference: Civil Rights and Judicial Resistance to Administrative Constitutionalism’ (2014) 2014(1) University of Chicago Legal Forum 223

Ross, Bertrall L, ‘Embracing Administrative Constitutionalism’ (2015) 95(2) Boston University Law Review 519

Roux, Theunis Robert, and Fritz Edward Siregar, 'Trajectories of Curial Power: The Rise, Fall and Partial Rehabilitation of the Indonesian Constitutional Court' (2016) 16(2) Australian Journal of Asian Law 121

Safa'at, A and Widiarto AE, "Conditional Decisions as Instrument Guarding the Supremacy of the Constitution (Analysis of conditional decisions of Indonesian Constitutional Court in 2003 – 2017)," (2021)Vol 8, No, Brawijaya Law Journal. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.21776/ub.blj.2021.008.01.06

Stacey, Richard, ‘Dynamic Regulatory Constitutionalism: Taking Legislation Seriously in the Judicial Enforcement of Economic and Social Rights’ (2017) 31(1) Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public Policy 85

Tamanaha, Brian Z, ‘Always Imperfectly Achieved Rule of Law: Comments on Jeremy Waldron’ (2021) 10(1) Global Constitutionalism 106

Tani, Karen M, ‘Administrative Constitutionalism at the “Borders of Belonging”: Drawing on History to Expand the Archive and Change the Lens’ (2019) 167(7) University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1603

Velasco, Julian, ‘Fiduciary Judgment Rules’ (2021) 62(4) William & Mary Law Review 1397

Waldron, Jeremy, ‘The Rule of Law and the Role of Courts’ (2021) 10(1) Global Constitutionalism 91

Waterman, Antonia, 'Book Review: Sovereignty's Promise: The State as Fiduciary' (2013) 20(4) Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 649

Wieringa, Saskia E, 'Criminalisation of Homosexuality in Indonesia: The Role of the Constitution and Civil Society (2019) 20(1) Australian Journal of Asian Law 227

Downloads

Published

2021-10-31

How to Cite

Tan, David. 2021. “Juxtaposing Fiduciary Constitutionalism and Administrative Constitutionalism in the Context of Enhancing the Indonesian Constitution”. Brawijaya Law Journal 8 (2):185-201. https://doi.org/10.21776/ub.blj.2021.008.02.02.